Autumn, reflection of trees and house in the lake. Landscape for background
Pocono Lake Communities

Pocono Lake Communities: A Buyer’s Guide to Lake Naomi, Arrowhead Lake, Indian Mountain Lakes and Lake Harmony

Dues, rental rules and the feel of the place change a lot from one gate to the next. Here’s how four of the region’s best known lake communities actually compare.

CT
Chris Troxell Team
November 2026 Lake Community Buyer’s Guide

There’s a particular kind of Pocono weekend that sells people on lake life: coffee on the dock, an afternoon at the beach club, a fire pit after dark. The communities that offer it, though, are anything but interchangeable. Dues, rental rules and the feel of the place change a lot from one gate to the next.

This guide compares four of the region’s best known lake communities so you can figure out which one fits how you plan to use your home. For more on the region as a whole, visit our Pocono Mountains community page.

The short version: Lake Naomi in Pocono Pines is the most upscale, with typical values around $436,000 and lakefront homes listed above $1 million. Arrowhead Lake and Indian Mountain Lakes offer more affordable entry points, often in the $300,000s, and both allow short term rentals with registration. Lake Harmony, in Kidder Township near Big Boulder and Jack Frost, pairs lake life with skiing. In every community, HOA dues and association rules sit on top of township short term rental permits.

The Basics

What to Know Before Buying in a Pocono Lake Community

Most Pocono lake communities are private, and many are gated. Owners pay annual dues to a homeowners or property owners association, which in turn maintains the roads, beaches, pools and security. Amenity access usually works through ID cards or wristbands, and renters typically need a temporary membership of their own.

The biggest thing buyers miss is that rental rules come in two layers. The township decides whether short term rentals are legal and what permits they need. The community association can then add its own registration, fees and limits or even ban rentals outright in some sections. Before you buy, your agent should pull the association’s documents and resale certificate so you know exactly what you’re agreeing to.

Two layers of rules, not one

Township permit requirements and community association registration are decided separately. A property that looks rental friendly on paper can still be restricted by its own association documents, so ask for both before you write an offer.

Community One

Lake Naomi: Upscale Lake Living in Pocono Pines

Lake Naomi, in Tobyhanna Township, is the most polished of the four. It’s actually two neighborhoods, Lake Naomi and Timber Trails, each with its own homeowners association. Owners in either can then join the Lake Naomi Club, which runs the beaches, pools, clubhouse and the golf course inside the Timber Trails gates.

Prices reflect the setting. Zillow put the typical home value in Pocono Pines at about $436,000 early this year, and lakefront or near lake homes regularly list well above $1 million. Short term rentals are allowed, but the paperwork is real. According to the Club’s own rental guidance, owners need a Tobyhanna Township permit ($600 to start, then $500 a year to renew) plus a $175 Club rental registration if guests will use the amenities, and the number of temporary memberships each home can offer is limited.

Typical Value

~$436K

Township

Tobyhanna

STR Permit

$600 / yr 1

Club Fee

$175 rental

Community Two

Arrowhead Lake: A Classic Pocono Vacation Community

Arrowhead Lake, in Pocono Lake, has been a vacation favorite for decades. The gated community spreads across parts of Coolbaugh and Tobyhanna townships and centers on a large lake with several beaches, plus pools, courts and a clubhouse. Residents wear wristbands at the amenities, and summer weekends have a lively, family feel.

It’s one of the more accessible lake communities on price, with many homes listing in the $300,000s. Annual association dues on recent listings have run around $2,000. Short term rentals are permitted, and owners register them with the Arrowhead Lake Community Association, whose renters must carry temporary membership ID at community facilities. Most homes here are on private septic systems, so plan your inspections accordingly.

List Prices

$300Ks

Annual Dues

~$2,000

Rentals

Allowed + register

Wastewater

Private septic

Most homes here are on private septic systems. Budget for a dedicated septic inspection rather than relying on a general home inspection alone — our guide to well and septic in PA walks through what that costs and what to look for.

Community Three

Indian Mountain Lakes: Big Amenities, Lower Dues

Indian Mountain Lakes, near Albrightsville, straddles the line between Carbon and Monroe counties. It offers several lakes and beaches, pools, a clubhouse, playgrounds and a staffed gate, and local listings frequently describe the dues as low for everything that’s included.

Homes commonly list from the mid $300,000s into the $500,000s, with building lots available for buyers who want to start from scratch. Most of the community is considered rental friendly, with short term rentals registered through the Indian Mountain Lake Civic Association and guests following its wristband policy. Not every section is the same, though. At least some lots carry covenants requiring a 30 day minimum rental, so confirm the rules for the specific property before you write an offer.

List Prices

$350K–$500K

Counties

Carbon & Monroe

Dues

Low for amenities

Vacant Lots

Available

Community Four

Lake Harmony: Lake Life Next to Big Boulder and Jack Frost

Lake Harmony isn’t a single gated community. It’s an unincorporated area of Kidder Township in Carbon County, home to Lake Harmony itself, Big Boulder Lake and several private developments, including Lake Harmony Estates, Split Rock and condo communities along the water. Big Boulder and Jack Frost ski areas sit right nearby, and Hickory Run State Park’s famous Boulder Field is a short drive away.

That combination of skiing in winter and boating in summer makes Lake Harmony one of the strongest year round rental markets in the region. Kidder Township allows short term rentals but requires an annual permit and inspection, and the township has raised its permit fees in recent years. Many of the private communities add their own approval steps, so check both layers before you buy.

Township

Kidder, Carbon

Skiing

Big Boulder & Jack Frost

STR Permit

Annual + inspection

Rental Demand

Year round

Rules & Costs

Short Term Rental Rules in Pocono Lake Communities

If rental income is part of your plan, build these costs and steps into your numbers from the start.

Township permit

Tobyhanna, Coolbaugh and Kidder townships all require short term rental permits, usually with an annual renewal and inspection.

Association registration

Most communities require you to register rentals, pay a fee and provide guest information before arrival.

Lodging taxes

Pennsylvania’s 6% hotel occupancy tax applies to short stays, and counties add their own hotel tax on top.

Rules that change

Fees and policies shift. Kidder Township has raised its permit fees, and owners in other Pocono communities have pushed back on new association rental charges.

None of this should scare off a good investment. It just means the same house can pencil out very differently depending on which side of a township line or community gate it sits.

Lifestyle

Year Round Living vs. a Weekend Place in the Poconos

Plenty of buyers start with a vacation home and end up living there full time. If that’s a possibility, look at the practical details early: how well the association plows its roads, whether the house runs on propane or oil, how reliable the internet is and which school district serves the address. Most of these communities fall within the Pocono Mountain School District, though Carbon County sections of Indian Mountain Lakes and Lake Harmony are served by other districts.

Our guide to living in the Pocono Mountains year round goes deeper on winters, commuting and everyday life once the summer crowds head home.

If it’s a weekend place

  • Confirm rental rules and dues before you fall for the house
  • Ask how the association handles off-season security
  • Budget the lodging tax and permit renewals annually

If it might be full time

  • Verify internet speed at the specific address
  • Check road plowing and who maintains them
  • Confirm the school district for that parcel, not the mailing address
Decision Time

How to Choose the Right Pocono Lake Community

Pocono Lake Communities FAQ

Find Your Pocono Lake Home

Whether you’re after a summer place on the beach or a ski season rental that pays its own way, the Chris Troxell Team can help you compare communities and read the fine print before you commit. Explore our Pocono Mountains page, review our buyer resources or contact our team to start your search.